Was that a strip search?

November 15, 2007

The venerable SCOTUSBlog (Can a blog be venerable? If so, this one is) has put the Maryland buttocks-search case on its list of cases that have a good chance of getting cert. It’s the fifth one down.

If you recall, back in June, the Court of Appeals voted 4-3 to reverse the conviction of John Paulino, whose upper buttocks were spread and searched at a car wash by a police officer looking for cocaine. (A tipster had told police that Paulino routinely hid his drugs between his cheeks.) The majority, led by Judge Greene, said that the police failed to protect Paulino’s privacy when they reached into his exposed undershorts. The dissenters, led by Judge Battaglia, said the search was reasonable; in a separate two-paragraph dissent, Judge Cathell said that if Paulino wanted privacy, he should not have worn his pants so low.

The state is asking the Supreme Court to clarify what constitutes a strip search and whether the Court of Appeals has now outlawed “entirely reasonable police conduct,” according to its cert petition.

Do you think SCOTUS will take this one? Did the Court of Appeals go too far here?

-CARYN TAMBER, Legal Affairs Writer

Comments

• 
  

• Law

  • Fabian’s not-so-happy New Year
  • This week in Maryland Lawyer
  • A bit of confusion over in-flight births
  • Think before you tweet, lawyers warn
  • A New Year’s Resolution worth keeping

• Business

  • Outlook isn't looking up for CEG stock
  • The year of Pat Turner
  • Fraser Smith brings his column to The Daily Record
  • Whose best practices would you subscribe to?

• 

• Archives

  Select Month January 2009  (4) December 2008  (82) November 2008  (74) October 2008  (90) September 2008  (75) August 2008  (85) July 2008  (94) June 2008  (102) May 2008  (100) April 2008  (90) March 2008  (68) February 2008  (74) January 2008  (79) December 2007  (80) November 2007  (78) October 2007  (90) September 2007  (60) August 2007  (72)

• Visit Eye on Annapolis

  Check out our blog on the legislative session, Eye on Annapolis.

• Categories

  Select Category 4th Circuit  (8) 6th Circuit  (2) aba  (1) advertising  (12) alcohol  (8) annapolis  (8) attorney general  (5) attorney grievance commission  (3) Ballard Spahr  (2) Baltimore  (134) baltimore county  (17) baltimore sun  (10) bankruptcy  (2) baseball  (8) Billy Murphy  (2) BRAC  (5) business  (551)    energy  (28) BWI airport  (4) cars  (10) charity  (4) college  (1) commute  (3) Constellation Energy  (8) construction  (4) copyright  (2) court of appeals  (24) court of special appeals  (9) crime  (15) d.c.  (2) D.C. Circuit  (1) Dale Cathell  (1) death penalty  (4) development  (9) disclosure  (1) discovery communications  (5) district court  (3) DLA Piper  (6) DNA  (4) Eastern Shore  (5) economy  (21) education  (13) ehrlich  (1) election  (1) entertainment  (12) environment  (25) estate planning  (2) executive compensation  (2) expert testimony  (1) Federal Hill  (1) fifth amendment  (1) film  (3) finance  (13) first amendment  (2) food  (14) foreclosure  (1) foreclosures  (7) frederick  (4) gambling  (5) general assembly  (1) golf  (11) government  (89) guns  (2) harbor east  (1) harford county  (1) hate crime  (1) health  (45) health care  (2) hilton  (1) holidays  (19) Honest Tea  (4) horses  (1) hotels  (4) howard county  (8) immigration  (3) internet  (6) iPhone  (1) johns hopkins  (12) judges  (4) jurors  (3) law  (585) law school  (11) Legg Mason  (2) libel  (1) living wage  (1) Loyola  (4) marketing  (17) Marriott  (3) Martin O’Malley  (3) maryland  (85) maryland lawyer  (10) Maryland Stadium Authority  (1) maryland state lottery  (1) media  (3) michael phelps  (3) Miles & Stockbridge  (1) military  (5) minorities  (1) money  (9) montgomery county  (27) mortgage  (1) Mount St. Mary’s  (1) MSBA  (3) multimedia  (24) music  (2) national harbor  (1) newspapers  (3) nonprofit  (3) obama  (5) Olympics  (1) Orioles  (18) Pat Turner  (1) Perdue Farms  (1) peter angelos  (2) pets  (15) Philadelphia  (2) photography  (1) politics  (47) port  (1) prince george’s county  (3) PSC  (1) public relations  (4) radio  (3) Ravens  (25) real estate  (54) recession  (2) recruiting  (3) regulation  (2) religion  (5) restaurants  (9) retail  (9) Rupert Murdoch  (2) salaries  (7) salisbury  (1) same-sex marriage  (2) settlement  (1) sheila dixon  (3) slots  (7) small business  (3) smoking  (3) smoking ban  (3) social networking  (1) sparrows point  (1) sports  (85) starbucks  (1) state fair  (1) stem cells  (1) steroids  (3) stocks  (2) Supreme Court  (27) surveys  (1) T. Rowe Price  (1) taxes  (27) technology  (47) the arts  (1) The Daily Record  (1) The Wire  (9) tourism  (9) Towson  (3) Towson University  (3) trademark  (1) training  (2) transit  (7) travel  (1) u.s. district court  (1) Uncategorized  (75) UnderArmour  (11) University of Baltimore  (9) university of maryland  (21) university of maryland-baltimore  (4) Venable  (3) Villa Julie  (3) virginia  (5) Wall Street Journal  (5) washington  (9) washington post  (3) Westboro Baptist Church  (2) wildlife  (4) women  (2) work  (13)